NFL analyst predicts 49ers will replace Brock Purdy with veteran QB

Amidst the flurry of bold predictions emerging as the NFL transitions into its offseason, SI.com’s Conor Orr offers a particularly unconventional forecast for the San Francisco 49ers.

He envisions a quarterback switch following the team’s Super Bowl defeat, with the sidelined Kirk Cousins taking the reins from Brock Purdy.

While Orr’s prediction ventures into off-the-wall territory, it’s not entirely implausible, especially given head coach Kyle Shanahan’s openness about contemplating luring Tom Brady out of retirement to lead the team, while Purdy develops in the background.

However, significant hurdles would accompany such a move, foremost among them the challenge of maneuvering within the team’s salary cap constraints. Cousins’ anticipated contract, ranging from a two-year, $60 million projection by Pro Football Focus to Spotrac’s three-year, $118 million estimation, present a formidable financial obstacle.

Nevertheless, considering the 49ers’ offensive arsenal and their penchant for bold moves, Cousins could indeed be an appealing prospect.

Benching Purdy would represent a dramatic decision for a quarterback who recently propelled the team to the Super Bowl, despite his struggles in the playoffs. Purdy’s regular-season performance, boasting 4,280 yards, 31 touchdowns, and an impressive 113.0 QB rating, contrasts starkly with his postseason showing, where he faltered under the pressure of the Chiefs defense.

The allure of adding a seasoned veteran like Cousins gains traction, particularly in playoff scenarios, where Purdy’s track record remains limited. Although Purdy holds a modest 1-3 record as a playoff starter, his performances have generally been steady, averaging 209.4 yards per game, five touchdowns, one interception and a 93.7 quarterback rating.

Realistically, the 49ers, currently approximately $11 million over the cap according to OverTheCap.com, are unlikely to seriously pursue replacing Brock Purdy with Cousins. Nonetheless, there’s a degree of rationale underlying the speculation, reflecting the perpetual strategic calculus of NFL team management.